
sixteen calamitous decisions by Cardiff Council - and how they effect you
Over the past few years, a string of connected decisions have damaged our city. Under its current leadership, Cardiff Council has consistently favoured the rich and powerful developers over citizens.
To expose this pattern of behaviour, Cardiff Civic Society has produced a dossier of the council’s worst decisions over the last five years. We set out how Cardiff Council bows and scrapes to vested interests whilst ignoring the ordinary citizens of this great city. All the examples used are in the public domain and links are provided to sources.
It is time to ask the question: who is the city for? Cardiff’s constant striving to become a ‘destination’ city has got out of kilter with the people’s priority of somewhere that is nice to live. The constant emphasis on destroying old buildings and green space stops Cardiff from being the pleasant, sustainable city we all want.
There is a lack of transparency in decision-making. Citizens are excluded from decisions. A small arrogant elite believe they know better than the rest of us about what’s good for this city. They operate in secrecy and prevent us from knowing the details of the decisions they take.
Cardiff Civic Society has produced a Vision for Cardiff which points the way to a different way to run the city, where decisions are made in co-operation with the people of Cardiff and the quality of life of residents and the sustainability of our way of life is paramount.
March 2022
-
Plans to sell-off green space for a Military Medicine Museum nobody wants
Cardiff Council is promoting plans to build a military museum on a children’s park in one of the city’s most deprived wards. People in Cardiff believe that Military museum is being dumped on them.
-
Destruction of mature trees – just to hike developers’ profits
Cardiff Council has co-operated with builders to destroy beautiful mature trees on public land - our land - with no good reason other than to help greedy developers make even more money.
-
Destruction of the Northern Meadows – green spaces trashed and hundreds of trees felled
Cardiff council has green lighted the destruction of 23 acres of meadow, ancient trees, shrub and grassland at the Northern Meadows. Cardiff council’s co-operation with developers wishing to build on treasured green spaces is part of a pattern of behaviour across the city.
-
Shameful neglect of our cultural heritage
Cardiff Council has stood by and allowed the neglect of Cardiff’s proud industrial and dockland heritage. It allowed the Cardiff Coal Exchange to fall apart and to pass into the hands of businessmen with poor reputations
-
Working class heritage destroyed
Cardiff Council give the strong impression that they don’t care about the cultural institutions of working class people. They stand back, as famous much-loved pubs are demolished and replaced. In one shameful example the council themselves were responsible for destroying an historic and culturally important community cafe - and refused to allow space for it in the replacement building.
-
Excluding low income households from city centre developments
Time after time in the last five years, Cardiff’s ruling group have prevented ordinary working people from living in new city centre housing schemes, by allowing powerful developers to get away with not providing any affordable accommodation - despite this being council policy
-
Ugly tower blocks disfiguring the city
Under its current leadership, Cardiff has seen a huge increase in tower blocks in the city centre. Tower blocks have replaced parks and vibrant music venues and locally owned restaurants. Cardiff Council has deliberately encouraged these developments through special planning guidance, which is designed to encourage high rises.
-
Failing to rebuild a bus station
Despite all its promises, Cardiff Council has failed in its promise to re-open the central bus station.
As a result, working people who rely on public transport have a far poorer service than before.
-
Nature under threat – Cardiff Council destroys habitat as many species face extinction
Cardiff Council’s current leaders have made it clear: builders’ profits are more important to them than tackling the nature crisis. They have consistently refused to introduce supplementary planning guidance which would protect ancient trees from being needlessly felled.
-
Failing to tackle inequality
Cardiff Council’s Wellbeing Plan shows that, pre-pandemic there was a 22-24-year difference in healthy life expectancy (the number of years that someone lives in good health) between the least and most deprived areas of Cardiff. And looking at children, the plan notes that nearly half of children in Ely are growing up in poverty, compared to just over 5% in Rhiwbina.
-
Risky secret deals with foreign developer - with over £200m of YOUR money.
It has not been shown that the investment of over £200m that Council will provide to Live Nation (US) the developers and operators of a proposed Arena in Atlantic Wharf, is the best use of public money at a time when many city services are stretched.
-
Worst in Wales at Recycling
According to official Welsh Government figures, Cardiff has the lowest recycling rates in the nation. This is primarily down to the city council’s failure after many many years to introduce a system which allows residents to separate their waste sufficiently.
-
Residents’ views ignored and denigrated at Cardiff Council planning committee - under a chair who was banned from teaching
In March 2021, a council official, who should be neutral, celebrated when the planning committee voted in favour of a highly controversial plan for a new incinerator in Splott. This shocking behaviour made the national news and exemplifies the council’s attitude to residents
-
Cycle lane policy takes footpaths away from pedestrians in parks
The council is unwilling to encourage real behaviour change by installing bike lanes along roads and instead has a policy of taking pathways in parks away from walkers.. Cardiff’s cycle lane network remains sub-standard in comparison with most northern European cities of a similar size and ambition.
-
Toxic waste pouring into Ely river
The news that pollution is pouring from Grangemoor park, for which the council is responsible, into the river Ely, exemplifies their terrible environmental record and incompetence. It is an example of the council failing in their basic duty to keep residents safe.
-
Cardiff's cladding scandal
Cardiff Council have removed the insulation cladding from three of its own tower blocks. However, it has not replaced the material with new safe components. As a result, council tenants are living in apartments which are more expensive to heat.